The 2019 WWE Women's Top 25: Midyear Edition
We’ve hit the halfway point in the year 2019. Lots has happened since January, especially so in the Federation. The women of WWE have been given quite the platform to perform this year. And while there is always room for change and improvements, it can’t be denied that there are still plenty who have shined brightly.
With six months having come and gone, it’s time to take a look at who the best of the best have been this year. So, I will be presenting a standalone edition of my Women’s Top 25. For those unfamiliar, here’s a crash course refresher on the process that’s used to compile this formula.
Anyhow, let’s take a look at some honorable mentions before we dive into who made the cut.
30. Candice LeRae (12.75 Pts)
29. Rhea Ripley (15.5 Pts)
28. Ember Moon (15.75 Pts)
27. Liv Morgan (16.5 Pts)
26. Ruby Riott (16.75 Pts)
This assembly of talent came close to making the cut, but ultimately fell short. There has ultimately been two factors working against these ladies this year: Workload and injuries.
Ember Moon, Rhea Ripley and Ruby Riott have spent time on the shelf this year. That plagued them quite a bit, as they weren’t able to get work as much they’d have liked. Especially so for Rhea, as NXT UK’s formula of cyclical tapings works against her as is. Ruby has been out since after WrestleMania, and we aren’t sure when she’ll come back.
Ember has been back since Mania, but continues to be shelved. Although, she did work just this past Tuesday.
Liv worked plenty in the first few months, but hasn’t seen the field since the Superstar Shakeup. A talent of her caliber would’ve benefited big from being on TV. But such luck was and has not been in the cards for her. If that luck can change, expect her to make some moves. Candice, meanwhile, was used sparsely. From the looks of it, that may change, and she’ll have to do a lot of work to pick up ground. Especially considering that she is nearly three points behind the 29th-ranked Ripley
Now, let’s get down to business, shall we?
25. Mia Yim
Matches in 2019: 7 | Points: 18
Mia Yim is blossoming into quite the contender. Her series of matches with Bianca Belair got her into the rankings and she was able to stay alive in the Top 25 at the midway buzzer. Yim’s trajectory seems to have her poised for bigger and better things in the summer. So, expect her to start making some moves in these rankings if her workload picks up as I expect it to.
24. Toni Storm
Matches in 2019: 6 | Points: 18.5
The NXT UK Champion checks in at 24th. Toni Storm and her ‘shiny shiny’ have only seen the field six times this year. She’s been working a lot in STARDOM in Japan and other places, and the cyclical nature of NXT UK’s taping schedule has likely worked against her in that regard. With that being said, I hope to see her compete more. She now seems destined to face off with Kay Lee Ray for her championship. That match could very well position her to vault up on this list if it goes well.
Matches in 2019: 9 | Points: 19.5
It’s been a pretty solid year for one Tamina. She competed in a variety of tag matches earlier this year with one Nia Jax, which aided her in getting in these rankings. She’s rarely been used since Nia left to take care of her injured knees. So, she slid as a result and wound up here. It probably says a lot that she hasn’t worked on TV since WrestleMania, but still finds herself in the Top 25. Either she will get more opportunities and climb the rungs, or someone else will soon enough.
22. Sarah Logan
Matches in 2019: 11 | Points: 20
Sarah Logan is the highest-ranked member of the group formerly known as The Riott Squad. Were you expecting that? Perhaps not, but Logan was a very steady hand when she was utilized. She did a very good job in the Elimination Chamber Match in February with her partner in Liv Morgan. She had the luxury of working a few more matches that hit compared to her peers, so that’s why she stands at 22. Logan has not been on TV (Main Event not withstanding) since an April 21 WWE Network special. If that soon changes, she might find a way to get going again.
21. Billie Kay
Matches in 2019: 16 | Points: 21.5
One-half of the longest reigning (HEY KAYLA!) and defending Women’s Tag Team Champions (HEY KAYLA!) finds herself at 21st. Billie Kay(LA!) has had herself a very fine year in the wrestling department. Her singles matches have lacked what her partner Peyton Royce has brought to the table, which will explain the differential between the two. When she works with Royce, she’s done a pretty fine job. I’d like to see more from her and Peyton in that regard, but it appears we might be set for that.
20. Sonya Deville
Matches in 2019: 13 | Points: 21.75
Sonya Deville is No. 20 in the midyear Women’s Top 25. Deville has long been noted as a talented prospect and she’s certainly shown promise when given the ball. Her TV matches, however, have been far too short for myself and others to truly see that. If her positioning on her is to change, then I think they need to take the proverbial kid gloves off her and let her work. I want to see what others say she has and what I believe she has in her as well. 20th is a very fine spot for her right now though to say the least.
19. Kairi Sane
Matches in 2019: 11 | Points: 23.25
It’s been a bit of an up and down year for Kairi Sane. None of it is particularly her fault, either. She had one TakeOver match, a Fatal 4-Way in Brooklyn. That and a one-on-one NXT Women’s Championship Match against Shayna Baszler have been her two biggest matches to date. The problem with that of course is that it’s just two matches. She has built up enough rapport so far to fall 19th here, but for her sake, her workload starts to increase so she can make a leap up. I believe she’s one of the most talented members of the women’s roster, and Top 10 status isn’t unattainable.
18. Lacey Evans
Matches in 2019: 10 | Points: 24
Common consensus on WWE Twitter leads you to believe that Lacey Evans stinks. While I think they’re exposing her quite a bit, and perhaps more than they should, I’d disagree that she stinks out loud. She’s been a perfectly fine and inoffensive wrestler. There are a lot of nitpickers that point out her botches and what have you, but the truth really lies in the middle. She hasn’t really wowed me in the ring, and I think her character work far outweighs her in-ring skills to this point. But that’s been a proven formula before, right?
Matches in 2019: 13 | Points: 24
Natalya finds herself tied up with Lacey Evans in the points department at the halfway point. Nattie has worked 13 matches this year, three more than Lacey. So you might be wondering how she’s tied up with her. Well, I gave five of Nattie’s 13 matches somewhere between the **-**3/4 range, while Lacey has just one. Some of that isn’t really her fault, as the length of some of her matches really prevented me from giving higher scores. Alas, that’s how the cookie crumbles. At this point, you know by now that she’s a safe and trusted worker with a medium-high ceiling.
Matches in 2019: 15 | Points: 25
Naomi finds herself 16th here in the WWE Women’s Top 25. She’s a very talented worker, and that’s apparent any time that they actually let her wrestle longer than a couple of minutes. See: Her performance in the Women’s MITB match. The problem, well, is just that. A lot of her matches, for whatever reason, have been incredibly short this year. That’s hurt the scores, and thus has hurt her positioning. Still, 16th is not a bad spot, and with a little more work, she may be able to catapult herself up higher.
15. Ronda Rousey
Matches in 2019: 13 | Points: 25.5
Ronda Rousey’s high ceiling and heavy workload at the start of the year got her to stay in the mix here. Rousey had an indisputably great match against Sasha Banks at the Royal Rumble. That, along with solid TV matches and the WrestleMania Women’s Main Event have given her quite a healthy cushion. I don’t foresee her being in the Top 25 by year’s end. She’s just 0.5 points ahead of Naomi, after all. But right now, she’s standing at 15th.
Matches in 2019: 14 | Points: 25.5
Carmella sits 14th at the halfway point in the Women’s Top 25. It hasn’t felt like she’s worked a lot this year, but she’s put in a high number of matches for the women this year with, coincidentally, 14. In the two Triple Threat Matches she’s been in this year on SmackDown, I think she’s had tremendous performances. More of that the rest of the way, and a Top 10 finish is not out of the question. She’s no doubt one of the most improved on the roster.
13. Peyton Royce
Matches in 2019: 17 | Points: 25.5
Remember that disparity I was talking about? Well, here you go. Peyton Royce is 13th in the WWE Top 25, while her partner is down at 21st. The differences between the two? It all comes down to the fact that Peyton has worked three singles matches this year. In those singles matches, she was able to pick up the four point difference between her and her partner. The best of the bunch? A match with The Man, Becky Lynch, back in January, in which she got three points.
12. Alexa Bliss
Matches in 2019: 11 | Points: 27.75
Do we have a little bit of a surprise here? No pun intended. Alexa Bliss sits 12th in the Women’s Top 25 in June, with just 11 matches under her belt. Listen, I know that there have been plenty of criticisms of her in-ring work. Perhaps those critiques have some weight. But ask yourself if she’s really had any duds this year. She really hasn’t. Among the 11 matches she’s had this year, I’ve given three of them **3/4 or less. All of those aforementioned matches were either short on time or very one-sided. Two of them were this past week. She’s been in the *** sweet spot four times for a lot of her singles matches. Slowly but surely, I think she’s piecing something together, and she’s been given the ball a lot lately while others haven’t. That would explain her upward trajectory to me.
Matches in 2019: 11 | Points: 27.75
Alexa and Asuka? Tied with the same points? And the same amount of matches? I’ll be honest: This probably wouldn’t be happening if The Empress wasn’t benched. She was putting out bangers left and right in the early part of this year. She was in my Women’s Match of the Year against Becky Lynch at the Royal Rumble, and the best main roster women’s TV match of the year against Charlotte Flair as well. If she gets the ball and runs again with it, she’s going to be in the Top 10 and perhaps the Top 5, as well.
10. Nia Jax
Matches in 2019: 11 | Points: 29.25
Nia Jax is 10th in the WWE Women’s Top 25. Despite not working since WrestleMania, Jax holds firm to a spot in the Top 10 primarily for a few reasons. The first reason is that a good amount of the multi-woman matches she was part of got high scores. The second reason is that she partook in BOTH the Women’s AND the Men’s Royal Rumble matches this year. Such an advantage holds quite a lot of weight. It is unknown as to if we’re going to see Nia in WWE again this year due to her ACL injuries. But, if she is, she may find herself susceptible to a jump. I think she’s been missed on Raw, but that’s just me.
9. Mandy Rose
Matches in 2019: 16 | Points: 30.5
Mandy Rose has the fourth-most matches among the women in WWE this year with 16. And yet, she’s only accumulated 30.5 points. That is more than The IIconics each have, to be fair. While a Top 10 finish at the midyear point is obviously a solid point, I think that there’s a bit of an issue here. I’ve given three of Mandy’s matches four stars. Those matches, however, were the Elimination Chamber Match for the Women’s Tag Team Championships, the Women’s Royal Rumble and the Women’s Money in the Bank Ladder Match. What do all of those matches have in common? They’re multi-woman matches. Looking further down the line, the second-highest grade for any of her matches this year was ***1/4, which I gave twice. Once in a tag team match with Sonya against Asuka and Kairi Sane, and once against Asuka in a singles match in February. So, again, another multi-woman match. Unfortunately for Mandy, I think she’s more of a compiler at this point, and that’s why she’s got such a high standing. That being said, there’s always room to improve, and hopefully she’s able to find herself here.
8. Shayna Baszler
Matches in 2019: 7 | Points: 31.75
With just seven matches under her belt, Shayna Baszler finds herself 8th in the Women’s Top 25. That should tell you just how damn good she is. Baszler wasn’t in the Top 10 heading into June’s final day of evaluations. However, her incredible Steel Cage Match against Io Shirai was enough to bounce her all the way up to this spot. Baszler’s booking has certainly been a knock, but that has nothing to do with her. The absolute lowest score that I’ve given a match of hers is ***1/4. Honestly, she might be the best in the entire Federation right now, and I won’t fight you if you argue with that. Her track record speaks for itself.
7. Io Shirai
Matches in 2019: 11 | Points: 32.75
Io Shirai may not have won the NXT Women’s Championship from Shayna Baszler. She, however, is ahead of her in the Women’s Top 25. Shirai ranks 7th at the halfway point after accumulating 32.75 points. She has four more matches than Shayna, but unfortunately a lot of the tag matches she worked with Kairi Sane were pretty short. Thus, I couldn’t really give high grades to them. She worked against the Horsewomen, as well, but those matches were a little rough around the edges. The 13.25 points she gained in June, including the 9 she got from the incredible cage match against Baszler this past Wednesday, really helped her finesse her way up to 7th on the countdown. She’s no doubt one of the best in the world, and I’m very excited to see how she works as a villainess now.
6. Charlotte Flair
Matches in 2019: 14 | Points: 33.75
Charlotte Flair is sixth after a pretty solid run through the first six months of the year. I think she’d be even higher on this list, but they really kept her workload to a minimum at the start of the year. In fact, from January 14-March 10, she only worked twice: a Triple Threat against Becky and Carmella, and the Royal Rumble Match. If she’d worked more TV matches, I think she’d no doubt be in the Top 5. But, she falls just shy of it at sixth in these rankings. Worth noting: There are just two points separating Charlotte, Io and Shayna. Could make for some fun down the way, eh?
5. Sasha Banks
Matches in 2019: 14 | Points: 34.5
The Boss? Top 5? Despite not working since WrestleMania? Your fave could absolutely never. Well… unless your fave is ahead of Sasha, but you get the point here. Banks had a really awesome run at the start of the year. Her match against Ronda Rousey is one of the best of the entire year, and is No. 2 among my women’s matches that have happened in 2019. A very close No. 2, at that. Her talent is obviously immeasurable and I definitely think the product’s missing her a bit, at least from an in-ring standpoint. Should she come back? Watch out. She’ll go on a torrid run again, I’m sure.
4. Bianca Belair
Matches in 2019: 11 | Points: 36
Bianca Belair has the opportunity to become one of NXT’s greatest homegrown success stories. Belair has put in serious work this year, despite working just 11 matches. She’s catapulted herself up to 4th in the Women’s Top 25 after the first half of the year. Belair’s peak was the match against Shayna in Phoenix. However she’s also been an awesome TV worker. Her series with Mia Yim these past few months was a treat to watch. The two never really missed, and so she was able to develop this cache she has right now. They made a mistake, I think, in not giving her the belt in Brooklyn, or at least in having her lose again. But, they need to turn her loose once more. Because she’s a phenomenal talent.
3. Nikki Cross
Matches in 2019: 17 | Points: 43.75
Speaking of success stories, let’s give a round of applause to Nikki Cross. Not only is Cross’ character work a delight to watch on the weekly, but she’s been working a lot of matches and shining brightly too. Her peak scores were in the Royal Rumble and Women’s MITB matches. But, she also had a delightful TV match with the aforementioned Bianca Belair back in June, plus a great Triple Threat Match with herself, Blair and Toni Storm at Worlds Collide in April. Cross has been so fun to watch, and being 3rd on this list says a lot about the talent that she possesses.
2. Becky Lynch
Matches in 2019: 18 | Points: 51.5
The Man has come around to No. 2 in the Women’s Top 25. No surprises here really, as Becky Lynch is the star of the show and has been given copious amounts of work. She’s second in matches this year among the women with 18. Her sweet spot has been in the ***-***3/4 range. I’ve given 10 of her 18 matches a score between 3-3.75 so far. Her peak scores have also been terrific, as she has three matches of ****+. That includes my Women’s Match of the Year, when she faced Asuka at the Royal Rumble, and got ****1/2, giving her nine points as a result. Lynch should be able to carry herself in this spot for a while, as she has a huge 8+ point lead on 3rd-ranked Nikki Cross, and a 15.5 point lead on 4th-ranked Bianca Belair.
Matches in 2019: 26 | Points: 74
What can you really say about Bayley this year? Other than that she’s been the workhorse of the division and has been outstanding in the ring. She hasn’t had the peaks that Becky, Asuka, Shayna, Io, Sasha or Ronda have had, or even to the extent that Charlotte had against Asuka in March. But she’s been so consistently good week in and week out that she’s built up a huge lead on the competition. It certainly helps that she’s worked just about every single week of TV this year. But she’s made the most of her opportunities. I’m biased for sure, but she’s absolutely been a blast to watch and is certainly worthy of the No. 1 spot in these rankings at the halfway point.