Rob and Chris recap the first-ever all-women’s PPV, which provided plenty of action from start to finish and all of the goods on what was an incredible night on Long Island.
TRISH STRATUS & LITA vs. ALICIA FOX & MICKIE JAMES
Chris Novak: Okay, this match was a super fun opener. This crowd is going to be n absolute hoot all night long. Trish and Lita both had some great spots and it feels like each could definitely have a couple of matches down the line. They set this match up for a hot tag with both Mickie AND Trish. Team Bestie won after Lita hit a Litasault on both Alicia and Mickie, which was then turned into a Chick Kick on Mickie. I have to give this ***1/4. Super-duper fun opener and a great way to get this event started.
Robert O’Neill: Wow. After Alexa Bliss got taken out of this match, my interest cratered a bit, but they certainly proved me wrong. It was really good! Trish and Lita can both still go (Trish in particular), and it was a wildly entertaining tag match to open the show. That’s been a WWE formula as long as I can remember, and it rarely disappoints. ***1/2
Chris Novak: Wow, I thought I was going to be the high man on this match! Rob usurped me by a 0.5 star.
20-WOMAN BATTLE ROYAL
Chris Novak: I clowned this beforehand. I said it was a silly idea even if it was expected. AND YET IT WAS SO FUN! They had plenty of little wrinkles in there that made it really fun. Nia Jax wound up winning, which was a little bit of a shock, as it came down between her and Ember. It’s possible that they could flip her to SDL, but regardless of decision, that was extremely fun. I’ll give it ***.
Robert O’Neill: Anyone who follows me on Twitter knows how little I was looking forward to this match. Holy crap, was I wrong. That was absolutely outstanding. It wasn’t as good as the Women’s Royal Rumble, but it was right up there to me. Nia Jax winning is perfectly fine, too. I think Nia and Ember Moon both looked great as the final two, the legends were fine, and everyone else got the job done. ***
MAE YOUNG CLASSIC FINAL: TONI STORM vs. IO SHIRAI
Chris Novak: Toni Storm gets the win! Storm and Shirai had a full-fledged sprint and it was extremely good. Lot of crazy spots busted out, including a smooth-as-hell moonsault by Shirai, a German Suplex on the apron, and a whole lot more. I am unsurprised by the result as there’s obviously a lot of hype around Storm. Really good stuff here. I’ll give it ***1/2 and go from there.
Robert O’Neill: This felt a little short, but it was still good. Really pumped to watch both of these two in NXT over the next few months. They’re both so different than anyone else on the NXT or WWE rosters, it could really be special. ***1/2
THE RIOTT SQUAD vs. SASHA BANKS, BAYLEY & NATALYA
Chris Novak: This was a rather crazy six-woman tag team match. A lot of wild stuff went down in this one, especially, as per the usual: Sasha going for broke. She took a wicked bump against the barricade in the latter stages of the match. Some tremendous theater late with Bayley protecting Sasha from a top rope senton splash by Ruby. The end sequence was pretty awesome. Nattie hit a powerbomb, Sasha hit an elbow drop and THREW HERSELF OUT OF THE RING TO TAKE OUT RUBY AND SARAH! And then Sasha hit a Frog Splash for the 1-2-3. ***3/4 for me. Just a whole lot of fun.
KAIRI SANE vs. SHAYNA BASZLER - NXT WOMEN’S CHAMPIONSHIP
Chris Novak: WOW… okay. So the match itself was really good. That’s no surprise considering who was involved. But… wow, they utilized Jessamyn Duke and Marina Shafir, two of the other Four Horsewomen, to help Shayna become the first-ever TWO-TIME NXT Women’s Champion! Shayna forced Sane into submission with her finisher and picked up the duke. Best match of the night so far if you ask me. ***3/4
Robert O’Neill: Wow. This was a surprising result. I think I liked it more than their match in Brooklyn, and I liked getting the other two Horsewomen involved, but I can’t help but to think it might have been a bad decision to take the belt off of Sane that quickly. Regardless, it was a fantastic match. ****
BECKY LYNCH vs. CHARLOTTE - LAST WOMAN STANDING MATCH FOR THE SDLIVE WOMEN’S CHAMPIONSHIP
Chris Novak: Holy shit. The greatest Last (Wo)man Standing Match in the company’s history. I’m not afraid to say it. *****
Robert O’Neill: Not only was this the best last (wo)man standing match of all time, it was the best womens match in WWE history. Charlotte deserves credit for improving after a rough start to the year, but Becky Lynch absolutely stole the show again. WWE finally realizes what they have in her and they’re not screwing it up It’s amazing. *****
RONDA ROUSEY vs. NIKKI BELLA - RAW WOMEN’S CHAMPIONSHIP
Chris Novak: A fantastic match to end the show. Ronda and Nikki both put in some serious work here and both took some really big bumps. Match was set up very well and Ronda defended herself well against the 2-on-1 disadvantage she faced. She eventually won via the armbar of course. Very good stuff. ***1/2 for me.
Robert O’Neill: This match was as good as everyone expected. Every match Ronda has wrestled in her short career has been good, and heel Nikki is so good. I liked the storytelling and getting Brie involved, and while it wasn’t quite as good as Becky/Charlotte, it was still an excellent main event. ***1/2
Chris Novak: Not one single match missed. There were good matches, very good matches, great matches and all-timers. Everyone stepped up to the plate and everyone hit it out of the park. The performers deserve to have their praises sung until the cows come home. This was the show of the year for WWE. It only solidifies, for me, the fact that the women are the straws that stir the drink in the company right now. A++++++++ for me.
Robert O’Neill: If you didn’t like this show, it’s because you formed that opinion long before tonight. This had something for everybody and was one of the best WWE PPVs of the year. The last three matches were absolutely excellent, the legends were used perfectly in the first two, and everything else was solid. A+